EuropeUSA 904 oils in 35 classes + 187 American oils in 10 classes SK · EN · DE · PL · Contact
Guide

Piotr Tester oil tests: what they measure and where to find the results

Piotr Tester is a Polish YouTuber who has run hundreds of engine oils through a friction test machine. Here is how his test works, what you can read from it and how to combine it with the parameters from data sheets.

The principle: the Timken test

Piotr Tester's machine works on a principle similar to the Timken test to ASTM D2782, which is used mainly for gear, industrial and EP oils. A steel cup rotates against a fixed steel block immersed in the oil, and the block is pressed against it with increasing force.

In the standard test the cup and block are cleaned thoroughly, run at a given load, and the width of the wear scar on the block is measured. The result is the Timken OK Load, the highest load in pounds or newtons at which the surface does not seize, or the scar width in millimetres at a set load. A higher OK Load and a narrower scar mean better protection under extreme load.

Piotr Tester's test is not a certified ASTM D2782 test. It has its own procedure, but the principle is the same: finding out how much load the oil film can carry.

How the test works

The oil is poured into a machine where a rotating metal shaft is pressed against a test piece. Weights are added step by step until the oil film gives way and the machine stops. The more load the oil carries, the better the result. The wear mark is then measured.

Tests are run at room temperature and at 100 °C, and the results are grouped into rounds. In round 4 the oil was heated to 100 °C but cooled quickly in the container. In round 5 both the oil and the container are heated to 110 °C, so the oil stays at about 100 °C during the test. Results from different rounds therefore should not be compared directly.

Where to find the results

Videos of the individual tests are on the Piotr Tester YouTube channel. The author also keeps a blog explaining the tests, including the difference between round 4 and round 5.

The author makes the full result tables available to supporters of the channel, as described in how to get access to the table. Below is the summary table of earlier tests that the author published on his blog, which you can sort and compare.

How to read the results

It is a test of oil film strength under extreme load on a test rig, not a test in an engine. It does not measure deposits, oxidation, cold start, volatility or suitability for particulate filters, and single measurements scatter.

When choosing oil, the carmaker's specification and the viscosity come first. The Piotr Tester result can help you decide between oils that already meet both.

Compare data sheet parameters

On Oilparameter you will find values for the tested oils that the rig does not capture: HTHS (film strength at 150 °C), TBN, sulphated ash and Noack volatility. See for example 5W-30, 5W-40, 0W-20 or 10W-40 oils.

Compare the results

Summary table of tests published by Piotr Tester on his blog (579 oils). Wear is the scar width in millimetres: the smaller, the better. A sample without oil measured 0.41 mm. The clean test is scored out of 10: the higher, the cleaner. Click a column to sort, tick up to 4 oils to compare.

amazingvery goodgoodweaker

Source: Piotr Tester blog, summary of all tables. The results belong to the author of the tests; newer rounds (4 and 5) are available from the author.

More guides