American motor oil comparison: API, ILSAC, dexos1 and data sheet values side by side
Pennzoil, Mobil 1, Valvoline, Castrol, Royal Purple, AMSOIL and more in one place. What the specifications on the bottle mean, which data sheet numbers are worth comparing, and how to pick an oil for your car.
Start with the owner's manual
The viscosity and specification in your owner's manual come first. Most American gasoline engines call for API SP or the newer API SQ, often together with ILSAC GF-6A or ILSAC GF-7A. Carmakers add their own: GM requires GM dexos1 Gen3, Ford lists specs such as Ford WSS-M2C962-A1, and Stellantis uses Chrysler MS-6395.
Any oil that meets these is adequate for a normal car, whatever the brand or price. Comparing numbers makes sense only between oils that already have the right specification and viscosity.
Which data sheet numbers to compare
HTHS (viscosity at 150 °C under high shear) shows how thick an oil film stays in the bearings under load. Between oils of the same grade, a higher HTHS gives more margin, for example when towing or in hot weather.
Noack volatility tells you how much oil evaporates at high temperature. Lower means less oil consumption and fewer deposits. TBN is the additive reserve for neutralising acids; a higher number helps with longer drain intervals.
CCS (cold cranking) and pour point show how the oil behaves in the cold. Viscosity at 100 °C and the viscosity index tell you how thick the oil is at operating temperature and how little it changes with temperature.
What American data sheets often leave out
Many American sheets give only viscosity, pour point, flash point and density. HTHS, Noack, TBN or sulfated ash are missing or shown only as a limit ("less than 15 %"). Our tables flag such values, and an empty cell means the maker did not publish the value, not that it is poor.
Flash point is measured by two methods: open cup (COC) and closed cup (PMCC). PMCC reads 10 to 30 °C lower, so we mark those values in the table.
High Mileage, V8s and diesel pickups
High Mileage oils contain seal conditioners that reduce leaks and oil consumption in engines with many miles. They meet the same specifications as regular oils, so they can be used in newer cars too.
Performance V8s such as the Mustang GT350, Corvette or SRT engines call for heavier 0W-40 or 5W-50 oils with the carmaker's own specifications. Classic V8s and older engines with wider clearances often run 20W-50. Diesel pickups need 15W-40 or 10W-30 oils meeting API CK-4.
Compare the oils in the table
The American oils section has the classes 0W-16, 0W-20, 5W-20, 5W-30, 10W-30, 0W-40, 5W-50, 20W-50 and 15W-40. In each table you can sort by any column, filter by brand and specification, and pick up to four oils to compare side by side. Every oil links to the manufacturer's data sheet.